The short answer

Tile outlasts nearly everything, but the underlayment beneath it fails at 20 to 30 years. Most older tile roofs need the tile lifted, the underlayment replaced and the tile relaid rather than a full replacement.

Specifications

FactorDetail
Typical cost$28,000 to $70,000
Tile service life50 years plus
Underlayment life20 to 30 years
WeightHeavy, may need review
HailBrittle under impact
WalkabilityCracks under foot traffic

Where it performs

The trade-offs

What we install

If someone quotes a full tile replacement on a 25 year old roof, ask specifically about lift and relay with new underlayment before agreeing.

Other materials

Compare directly: roofing comparisons · cost guide · glossary